General Discussion

General DiscussionFun question on dota mmr

Fun question on dota mmr in General Discussion
Son

    If a support main plays with a mid main in normal matchmaking on fresh steam accounts all the way to level 13, the support will lose out on mmr because obviously his/her kda, gpm, xpm, etc will be much lower. How much lower do you think?

    Bad Player

      My girlfriend mains support, while I main carry, she's got approx 50 lower ranked MMR than me.

      If I understood your question correctly.

      Son

        ^
        Kind of. This is going by normal matchmaking wins and then playing your 10 calibration games

        KAISLE

          Probably like 1k mmr lower. At some point smurf detection fades away and it becomes +-25 for every win/loss like in regular ranked matchmaking.

          King of Low Prio

            KDA is not just Kill/deaths, support players can get high KDA because of the assists they can obtain

            FlipFlop

              My bro play support and he have the same mmr as me

              King of Low Prio

                http://dotabuff.com/players/62560319

                my brother has 4k MM too and I make him my ward bitch....

                FlipFlop

                  Bro doto best doto sampson

                  Son

                    @sampson
                    the support can have a high KDA but his gpm and xpm will be at least a good 200-300 lower. This will factor into his mmr. Plus, you have to keep in mind that this is only considering if the one person plays just carry and the other plays just support

                    This comment was edited
                    King of Low Prio

                      look at players like Notail, if players who played supports got ranked lower because their gpm was lower each game u would not see them above 5k.

                      If you take ALL the end game stats of any avg 4k player they would be higher than Notail easy but it takes into account your game impact rather than just the stats you see on the scoreboard

                      6_din_49

                        I play support only on ranked and I've been around the 3500 mmr from the first calibration game (currently 3585 mmr). My minimum mmr was ~3350 and maximum ~3610, in about 100 ranked games. I'd say normal matchmaking was quite accurate in my case.

                        This comment was edited
                        Son

                          @sampson
                          this is assuming you start from level 1 to 13 playing just normal games as support, then playing your calibration games as support. That is a totally different situation

                          BoJack

                            during first games most important factor is Hero Damage

                            Son

                              ^
                              which effectively means support gets shafted on, but my question poses how much shafting does the support get

                              cartographer

                                Hero roles play an important factor in establishing the initial MMR. On my main, I play more 4th/5th position; 1st/2nd on my smurf. MMR difference was around 500.

                                Son

                                  ^
                                  which is where the huge flaw comes in for dota matchmaking

                                  FlipFlop

                                    if u get 4,5k when you think you are 5k player, just climb to 5k then. easy.

                                    <font face="wide latin">N...

                                      KDA aint a factor in support i only got 3.8k mmr :(

                                      60fps+

                                        Difficulty in dota 2 roles goes like this:
                                        (5 stands for hardest and 1 for easiest)

                                        5.Support/Offlaner
                                        4.Roamer
                                        3.Mid/Dual lane
                                        2.Trilane
                                        1.Jungler

                                        Some people may disagree but that's not the point. The point is that chances are that a support player with 4-5k mmr may make it to TI4 but a semicarry or a hardcarry with the same rating probably won't and that's the difference. And that's why Dota 2 is the most balanced MOBA you will find out there, old school. And since you really want to improve at the carry role you have to know that especially in public, unranked games you should be able to take the lead sometimes and carry your team to victory even when everyone has a negative score or an even score and you are the only with the most kills in your team. And if you think closely about it, that is the ideal case for every carry player, isn't it?

                                        This comment was edited
                                        King of Low Prio

                                          ROFL 4k MM players going to TI4 wtf are you smoking LOL

                                          Hopeless

                                            4-5k in ti4?

                                            omg... c'mon.

                                            5.3-5.4k solo queue players who are on a losing streak ok maybe. thats the lowest any TI player is going to be. any if those supports on a pro team will still stomp 4k pubs with any hero.