This is indeed a bug. The bug is in how how the data is shown on the match list page, not the accuracy of the data itself.
Explanation: The player in question actually received an abandon, but the two pages are showing that in a different way. Historically we've represented abandons as losses, and that is how it appears on the player profile. The bug is that we've recently introduced a new view in the player match list, which isn't properly displaying the result as an abandon.
I'll get that fixed shortly. Thanks for the report!
Please sign in to post comments.
So I had this game http://dotabuff.com/matches/623983179 where Void rage quit early on and game was marked as Safe to Leave. We proceeded and won the game. Now, visiting Voids dotabuff profile (main page) shows the match as lost for him (as it should be, he leaved the game after first blood) but when you proceed to Matches page http://dotabuff.com/players/136101011/matches you can see the Void's match is marked and displayed as VICTORY but it should be LOST.
I haven't checked if this is already being posted, known or just a situational issue.
Thanks.