General Discussion

General DiscussionCarry as pos 4

Carry as pos 4 in General Discussion
1 MMR

    Does anyone have a replay for playing a usual pos1 carry as a roaming support?

    arin

      half of my solo rmm games

      despair

        Morpling pos 4 works...i guess

        1 MMR

          I meant a hero who can gank at levels 1-2 and flash farm by 20 min

          Most pos3 heroes fall behind on creep score and rely on creating space for the team

          Anomaluna

            Most would require level 2, like morphling. Even pudge really starts to become effective at 2, unless you're already good with approach points. But CK is pretty legit.

            My suggestion, don't pick position 1 if you wanna roam. If you only know how to have good impact in the early game and then fall off and start dying because of over aggressiveness in the mid game, you're playing wrong. Picking a carry to start farming after the laning stage and stealing it from your safe lane will only hurt you. Start ganking with your offlane and supports with smokes.

            This comment was edited
            A

              watch zdonfrank riki.
              u start roaming until 10+ minute and u buy midas to farm

              This comment was edited
              Väinämöinen

                CK works and has been picked as pos 4 (very rarely though) for quiet sometime

                its just flat 3k normal MM but still (thats actually also pos 5 CK, so pos 4 with some farm would be even better)
                https://www.dotabuff.com/matches/3314902103

                naga also works, the root plus armour reduction is pretty good to gank, if your ally in the lane has some lock down as well

                was actually a pos 5 game, but pos 4 should also work i guess
                https://www.dotabuff.com/matches/3201845036

                also roaming zeus, 2 of my games (both won)

                https://www.dotabuff.com/players/382032027/matches?hero=zeus

                This comment was edited
                Väinämöinen

                  Also i remember some pro team playing a roaming sven in a match, but i dont remember which team or wat lan it was

                  despair

                    Weaver works too..i guess as pos 4, i've seen pos 4 weaver on youtube

                    RIP

                      well its not a carry but sandking ganks at early game and flashfarms at min 20 midgame stuff

                      🍩🍪Cookie🍪🍩

                        transitioning into a core as a pos 4 is very very very rare these days

                        evy

                          I do the opposite
                          I pick riki and snatch my pos 1's farm and go abandon after going 0-2
                          :)

                          Batatinha

                            But why?
                            Cores usually are the weakest part of the team in the early stages, why would you use this kind of hero to apply pressure?
                            If you are way better than your bracket, maybe works in a few games, but most of the time you'll ruin your team by staying underfarm, underlvl and with no impact

                            Batatinha

                              you're watching too much singsing matches

                              MonkaS

                                just why ?

                                Väinämöinen

                                  No you are being a typical low skill player without the ability the think outside the box.

                                  there are heros that usually are played as pos 1 that can be effective as pos 4.

                                  It probably never ocurred to you but under the "guide section" you can select other guides and buy different items and lvl your skills in a different order!!!!111
                                  you dont need to buy manta and heart on CK to be effective, you can also roam, max stun and rift first, buy solar crest drum rod of atos and use your ulti to push. and POOF! suddenly you have a legit pos 4 support, just by buying different items

                                  This comment was edited
                                  arin

                                    ah you meant it the other way around
                                    usually my pos 1 sinks down to pos 4 for whatever reason

                                    Story Time

                                      position 4 for PA/Ck could be tempting but i have not seen a viable gameplay of it

                                      Batatinha

                                        @killstealreporter
                                        ck has a rng disable, you can't engage early skirmishes trust only in it. That's why Mirana isn't a reliable roammer without another support with lockdown.
                                        and before you say i can't think out of the box, look at my profile, you're right, i'm a low skill player but i allways try different heroes in different positions. That's why i'm saying that a pos 1 playing as roammer doesn't work. usually pos 4 heroes strugle to get xp, most of pos 1 heroes can't shine in this scenario

                                        Dog

                                          I used to play pos 4-5 alch a long time ago, maybe the nuke dmg talent might make him mildly viable again
                                          Or not

                                          GRANT MACDONALD

                                            Priestess of the Moon

                                            Väinämöinen

                                              let me tell you again. CK has been played as pos 4 for a long time.
                                              im not the only one that did this

                                              oh wow https://www.dotabuff.com/matches/3159326435
                                              this 4k player randomly decided to play CK roaming pos 4??? or maybe he got the idea to play this, because people have been playing it before

                                              This comment was edited
                                              Stentorian

                                                Sven. Max Q and E.

                                                evy

                                                  Pos 4 void I have 100% with that
                                                  Kappa

                                                  evy

                                                    Weaver, CK, venge, etc

                                                    despair

                                                      Visage :D

                                                      Mlada i Luda

                                                        dont try to apply things you watch from sing sing stream ... pls

                                                        UnSure

                                                          Empire just drafted a support sven

                                                          Riguma Borusu

                                                            ^wat

                                                            UnSure

                                                              @RPQ-sama playing now, overpower cup

                                                              UnSure

                                                                They lost

                                                                Shou

                                                                  I've done roaming spec
                                                                  Don't try unless u want ultra cancer
                                                                  Roaming ck is legit tho
                                                                  Roaming pa used to be legit when dagger had a rlly long range lvl 1.

                                                                  주 롄양

                                                                    the hero shud at least hav some disable/slow at least

                                                                    u wont ever run clinkz as roamers

                                                                    MILNOR

                                                                      more obsession with being the carry

                                                                      MILNOR

                                                                        This comment was edited
                                                                        Dark Hunter

                                                                          Alchemist. max stun and passive. ez ganks ez farm.

                                                                          Aquinas

                                                                            Get me out

                                                                            lebron james jr

                                                                              Pugna can work I think

                                                                              Shou

                                                                                I'd rather run clinx or huskar as a roamer than Spectre
                                                                                Oov on ranged and provide the dmg in a gank rather than the disable.

                                                                                Nile

                                                                                  Lina is the only one that's decent, she is very strong early levels, and she is able to flash farm which all heroes mentioned above lacks.
                                                                                  https://www.dotabuff.com/matches/3280181815
                                                                                  I babysitted my Luna for 10 min, and smoke ganked for sf once or twice. Then I afk jungles while my team farms lane and enemy jungle with full vision(wards I placed). Also I joined pretty much every big fights.

                                                                                  Nile

                                                                                    I did this because my ck and Luna was pretty bad.

                                                                                    Dog

                                                                                      Alchemist. max stun and passive. ez ganks ez farm.

                                                                                      Max passive when you are roaming? No.

                                                                                      The proper build is max acid, next stun. The -armor from acid amplifies the damage from stun.

                                                                                      Also, no pu55i when charging stun. literally every alche player I meet is afraid of charging stun beyond .5 of a second.

                                                                                      evy

                                                                                        ^i dont
                                                                                        not to mention i stun myself everytime

                                                                                        🍩🍪Cookie🍪🍩

                                                                                          zzzzz low mmr stupidity